Water sources · Wastewater
Septic Systems, Cesspools and Sewers on Long Island
Wastewater is not a water source, but on Long Island it is the other half of the story. Roughly 360,000 Suffolk homes and tens of thousands in Nassau send their wastewater into the ground through a cesspool or septic system, and the nitrogen it carries reaches the same shallow aquifer that private wells and some public wells draw from. What is under your lawn affects your neighbour's well, the bay at the end of the street, and in the long run the supply everyone shares.
At a glance
Pros and cons
Advantages
- Sewers: nitrogen removed at the plant; no system to maintain; nothing under the lawn.
- Septic: works anywhere sand drains; no sewer charge; decades of service with pumping.
- Cesspools: cheapest to install and, where legal, to keep.
- I/A systems: remove most nitrogen on-site; county and state grants cover a large share of the cost.
Trade-offs
- Sewers: hookup costs and sewer fees; construction takes years and reaches few new areas.
- Septic: passes nitrogen to the aquifer; needs pumping every few years; a failed field is expensive.
- Cesspools: no treatment at all; banned for new installs in Suffolk; failure can reach a nearby well.
- I/A systems: an electrical component to maintain; a service contract; still a leaching field underneath.
Three ways the water leaves the house
A sewer carries wastewater to a treatment plant, which removes most nitrogen and discharges to the ocean, the Sound or a bay. Nassau County is largely sewered; the main exceptions are North Shore communities from Great Neck to Oyster Bay. Suffolk is the reverse: the south-west is sewered and most of the rest of the county is not.
A septic system is a tank that settles solids followed by a leaching field that lets the liquid soak into the sand. It handles solids well and does almost nothing for nitrogen; a conventional system releases on the order of 40 pounds of nitrogen a year into the ground, by Suffolk County's estimate.
A cesspool is older and simpler: a pit that holds solids and leaks liquid straight into the surrounding soil. Suffolk no longer permits new cesspools and requires a failed one to be replaced with at least a septic tank. Many Long Island houses built before the 1970s still have one.
Why nitrogen is the island's wastewater problem
Sand filters bacteria well but lets nitrate pass. Nitrate from septic systems and fertilizer is the most widespread contaminant in Long Island's shallow aquifer, the reason private wells in dense unsewered areas run high, and the reason the state's Long Island Nitrogen Action Plan exists. It also feeds the algae blooms that close bays and kill shellfish.
The answer the counties have settled on is the innovative/alternative onsite wastewater treatment system, or I/A OWTS: a small treatment unit that removes most nitrogen before the water reaches the ground. Suffolk's Reclaim Our Water program and Nassau's SEPTIC program pay grants toward replacing a cesspool or conventional septic with one; Nassau's page states grants up to $20,000.
What it means for your drinking water
If you are on a private well in an unsewered area, the cesspools around you are the most likely source of nitrate in your test results, and bacteria if a system fails close to the wellhead. Distance, depth and the condition of the well cap matter more than anything you can buy.
If you are on public water, your supplier's nitrate figure is on your community page. In unsewered parts of Suffolk, it is often the number closest to its limit.
What to do
If this is your water
1.Find out what you have
The property survey, the house file at the town building department, or the last pumping company's records will say cesspool, septic or sewer.
2.If you have a cesspool, check the grant programs
Suffolk's Reclaim Our Water and Nassau's SEPTIC program pay toward a nitrogen-reducing replacement; both have income and property eligibility rules on their sites.
3.If you are on a well, test for nitrate and bacteria every year
These are the two wastewater signatures. Keep the wellhead sealed and as far from any leaching structure as the lot allows.
4.Treat nitrate at the tap, not the house
Reverse osmosis under the kitchen sink reduces nitrate where you drink and cook; carbon filtration does not touch it. A free in-home test shows whether it is a question for your house.
Questions
Common questions
Sources
Start here
Find out what reaches your tap.
A free in-home test measures what is actually in your water, whatever its source, and tells you whether treatment is worth it and when a certified laboratory test is the right next step.