Skip to content
Fieldstone Water Co.

Suffolk County · Private wells (West Neck Water District (SCWA, Distribution…)

Water Quality in Shelter Island Heights, NY — What’s In Your Water

Shelter Island Heights's water is supplied by West Neck Water District (SCWA, Distribution Area 66). The most recent published results show PFOS at 2 ng/L, PFOA at 2 ng/L. Every figure below is shown against its NY or EPA limit and cited to its source.

Reported contaminants

Shelter Island Heights water, by the numbers

Data: SCWA 2026 Drinking Water Quality Report (2025 data) · Verified 2026-09-14

ND means not detected. Units: µg/L is micrograms per liter (parts per billion); ng/L is nanograms per liter (parts per trillion); mg/L is milligrams per liter (parts per million). Status uses the words below, near, exceeds, or trace — not color alone.

Source: Suffolk County Water Authority 2026 Drinking Water Quality Report (2025 data) (opens in a new tab)

Contaminants reported in Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County drinking water, with detected level, regulatory limit, and status.
SubstanceDetected levelLimitStatus
PFAS
PFOS (about this substance)2 ng/LRange ND–410NYS MCLBelow limit
PFOA (about this substance)2 ng/LRange ND–510NYS MCLBelow limit
PFBS (about this substance)ND ng/LRange ND–350000NYS MCL (unspecified organic contaminant)Trace — detected in some samples
PFPeA (about this substance)ND ng/LRange ND–350000NYS MCL (unspecified organic contaminant)Trace — detected in some samples
PFHxA (about this substance)ND ng/LRange ND–250000NYS MCL (unspecified organic contaminant)Trace — detected in some samples
Tested for and not detected (6): 6:2 FTS (about this substance), PFBA (about this substance), PFHpA (about this substance), PFHxS (about this substance), PFNA (about this substance), PFPeS (about this substance)
Industrial solvents & 1,4-dioxane
Tested for and not detected (6): 1,4-Dioxane (about this substance), cis-1,2-Dichloroethene (about this substance), 1,1-Dichloroethene (about this substance), Tetrachloroethene (PCE) (about this substance), 1,1,1-Trichloroethane (about this substance), Trichloroethene (TCE) (about this substance)
Nitrate, metals & inorganics
Tetrahydrofuran (about this substance)ND µg/LRange ND–10.72Highest single result 10.72 µg/L. The report's violation column is No.5NYS MCL (principal organic contaminant)No violation reported
Nitrate (about this substance)4.10 mg/LRange 2.11–5.7310EPA MCLBelow limit
Turbidity (about this substance)ND NTURange ND–0.905EPA MCLTrace — detected in some samples
Iron (about this substance)43 µg/LRange ND–197300NYS secondary standardBelow limit
Chloride (about this substance)23.0 mg/LRange 14.8–44.6250NYS secondary standardBelow limit
Manganese (about this substance)23 µg/LRange ND–100300NYS secondary standardBelow limit
Sulfate (about this substance)12.5 mg/LRange 9.0–19.3250NYS secondary standardBelow limit
Ethyl Benzene (about this substance)0.17 µg/LRange ND–1.855NYS MCL (principal organic contaminant)Below limit
Perchlorate (about this substance)ND µg/LRange ND–0.5018NYS MCLTrace — detected in some samples
Chromium (total) (about this substance)1.1 µg/LRange ND–1.6100EPA MCLBelow limit
Barium (about this substance)0.02 mg/LRange ND–0.042EPA MCLBelow limit
Hexavalent Chromium (about this substance)0.93 µg/LRange 0.22–1.62100EPA MCLBelow limit
Diethyltoluamide (DEET) (about this substance)ND µg/LRange ND–0.4350NYS MCL (unspecified organic contaminant)Trace — detected in some samples
Zinc (about this substance)ND mg/LRange ND–0.045NYS secondary standardTrace — detected in some samples
Sucralose (about this substance)0.31 µg/LRange ND–1.9950NYS MCL (unspecified organic contaminant)Below limit
Saccharin (about this substance)ND µg/LRange ND–0.1750NYS MCL (unspecified organic contaminant)Trace — detected in some samples
Acesulfame-K (about this substance)0.15 µg/LRange ND–0.7250NYS MCL (unspecified organic contaminant)Below limit
Ibuprofen (about this substance)ND µg/LRange ND–0.1250NYS MCL (unspecified organic contaminant)Trace — detected in some samples
Alkalinity (about this substance)89.2 mg/LRange 54.0–121.3No regulatory limit—
Bromide (about this substance)ND µg/LRange ND–61.6No regulatory limitTrace — detected in some samples
Calcium (about this substance)9.2 mg/LRange 6.2–12.4No regulatory limit—
CO2, calculated (about this substance)13.9 mg/LRange 1.0–33.1No regulatory limit—
Hardness (total) (about this substance)37.0 mg/LRange 21.2–47.2No regulatory limit—
Magnesium (about this substance)3.41 mg/LRange 1.41–4.80No regulatory limit—
pH (about this substance)7.2 pH UnitsRange 6.6–8.3No regulatory limit—
pH, field (about this substance)7.4 pH UnitsRange 7.0–7.5No regulatory limit—
Phosphate, total (about this substance)0.42 mg/LRange ND–0.64No regulatory limit—
Potassium (about this substance)1.68 mg/LRange 0.79–2.59No regulatory limit—
Silicon (about this substance)7.5 mg/LRange 5.5–9.6No regulatory limit—
Sodium (about this substance)55.0 mg/LRange 26.3–88.4No regulatory limit—
Specific conductance (about this substance)297 umho/cmRange 216–462No regulatory limit—
Strontium (about this substance)0.065 mg/LRange 0.049–0.105No regulatory limit—
Total Organic Carbon (TOC) (about this substance)ND mg/LRange ND–0.7No regulatory limitTrace — detected in some samples
Radon-222 (about this substance)120 pCi/LRange 120–120No regulatory limit—
Tested for and not detected (47): Carbamazepine (about this substance), Dilantin (about this substance), 5-(4-Hydroxyphenyl)-5-Phenylhydantoin (about this substance), Imidacloprid (about this substance), Lamotrigine (about this substance), Meprobamate (about this substance), Phenobarbital (about this substance), Primidone (about this substance), Stevioside (about this substance), Aluminum (about this substance), Ammonia (as N) (about this substance), Arsenic (about this substance), Boron (about this substance), Cobalt (about this substance), Color (about this substance), Copper (about this substance), Fluoride (about this substance), Lithium (about this substance), Molybdenum (about this substance), Nickel (about this substance), Nitrite (about this substance), Titanium (about this substance), Uranium (about this substance), Vanadium (about this substance), Alachlor ESA (about this substance), Alachlor OA (about this substance), Chlordane (about this substance), Metalaxyl (about this substance), Metolachlor (about this substance), Metolachlor OA (about this substance), Tetrachloroterephthalic Acid (about this substance), Chlorobenzene (about this substance), Chlorodifluoromethane (about this substance), Chloromethane (about this substance), Dichlorodifluoromethane (about this substance), 1,1-Dichlorethane (about this substance), 1,2-Dichloropropane (about this substance), Methylene Chloride (about this substance), MTBE (about this substance), o-Xylene (about this substance), p,m-Xylene (about this substance), 1,2,4-Trichlorobenzene (about this substance), Trichlorofluoromethane (about this substance), 1,2,3-Trichloropropane (about this substance), 1,1,2-Trichlorotrifluoroethane (about this substance), Gross alpha (about this substance), Gross beta (about this substance)
Lead & copper
Copper (tap samples) (about this substance)0.604 mg/L(90th percentile)Range 0.152–0.7491.3EPA action levelBelow limit
Lead (about this substance)ND µg/L(90th percentile)Range ND–1.2615EPA action levelTrace — detected in some samples
Disinfection byproducts
Free Chlorine (about this substance)1.00 mg/LRange 0.60–1.494EPA MRDLBelow limit
Chloroform (about this substance)1.73 µg/LRange ND–7.1980EPA MCLBelow limit
Trichloroacetic Acid (about this substance)ND µg/LRange ND–0.5660EPA MCLTrace — detected in some samples
Dibromoacetic Acid (about this substance)ND µg/LRange ND–0.4860EPA MCLTrace — detected in some samples
Bromoform (about this substance)ND µg/LRange ND–0.5080EPA MCLTrace — detected in some samples
Dibromochloromethane (about this substance)0.28 µg/LRange ND–1.1880EPA MCLBelow limit
Bromodichloromethane (about this substance)0.27 µg/LRange ND–0.9580EPA MCLBelow limit
Chlorate (about this substance)0.19 mg/LRange 0.07–0.88No regulatory limit—
Tested for and not detected (4): Bromochloroacetic Acid (about this substance), Bromodichloroacetic Acid (about this substance), Dichloroacetic Acid (about this substance), Monochloroacetic Acid (about this substance)

Water characteristics

Water characteristics reported in Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County drinking water.
SubstanceDetected levelLimitStatus
Sodium Cyclamate (about this substance)ND µg/L50NYS MCL (unspecified organic contaminant)Not detected

Status reflects the average of all samples. Individual readings may be higher; see range.

Values are ranges/averages across all wells feeding each distribution area at the entry point. A home near an area boundary may receive water from the adjacent area. SCWA's map shows the West Neck Water District (Distribution Area 66) covering this part of Shelter Island; most of the island is on private wells. Some homes here draw from private wells. These results do not apply to well water. Area assignment is read from SCWA's distribution-area map. Confirm your address with SCWA's See My Water Quality lookup (https://www.scwa.com/mywaterquality/ (opens in a new tab)). Only 1% of Shelter Island Heights's land lies inside any public water service area, per the NYS Department of Health boundaries EPA publishes; homes here are on private wells.

Your water district

Who supplies Shelter Island Heights’s water

EPA compliance

Federal violation record for Shelter Island Heights’s suppliers

The annual report above lists what was found in the water. EPA’s compliance database records whether each supplier met its testing, treatment, and reporting obligations.

Compliance counts are EPA Safe Drinking Water Information System records pulled directly from EPA. Most violations are monitoring or reporting lapses, not unsafe water; health-based violations (a contaminant limit, disinfectant level, or treatment technique) are counted separately. A system listed for a ZIP code may serve only part of it.

What the numbers mean

Shelter Island Heights has a high share of private-well households, and private wells are not covered by any utility's public report — the only way to know your numbers is to test. Suffolk groundwater carries Long Island's signature contaminants: 1,4-dioxane (a hard-to-remove industrial solvent New York now caps at 1 µg/L), PFAS "forever chemicals," and elevated nitrate and iron from decades of land use. Treating well water usually means a staged system rather than a single filter.

What this means for filtration

Matching Shelter Island Heights’s water to a system

For Shelter Island Heights, the numbers point first to under-sink reverse osmosis, whole-house carbon filtration, and private well treatment: dissolved contaminants close to their limits.

  • Recommended

    Under-Sink Reverse Osmosis

    Dissolved contaminants close to their limits

    Nitrate averaged 4.1 mg/L (limit 10), moderate but present; reverse osmosis reduces it at the tap. PFOA/PFOS reached 5 ng/L (ppt) in at least one sample — under New York's 10 ppt limit but at or above the 4.0 ppt federal MCL, with federal compliance due April 26, 2029. Whether an under-sink reverse osmosis model reduces PFOA or PFOS depends on that model's certification or performance data sheet. Sodium averaged 55 mg/L, above the 20 mg/L level New York flags for sodium-restricted diets. Perchlorate was detected up to 0.5 µg/L (limit 18).

    Explore Under-Sink Reverse Osmosis
  • Recommended

    Whole-House Carbon Filtration

    Chlorine residual 1 mg/L

    Free chlorine averaged 1 mg/L at the entry point (limit 4), the residual that gives tap water its pool taste and dries skin and hair. Chlorination by-products (trihalomethanes) reached 7.19 µg/L in some samples against an 80 µg/L limit for the group; they are absorbed in the shower as well as drunk.

    Explore Whole-House Carbon Filtration
  • Recommended

    Private Well Treatment

    Private wells in part of the community

    Part of Shelter Island Heights is on private wells that none of these figures cover; a well needs its own test, and a well package is sized to what it finds.

    Explore Private Well Treatment
  • Not needed here

    Whole-House + Softener Combo

    Hardness 37 mg/L, about 2.2 grains per gallon

    At 37 mg/L (2.2 gpg) the water is soft. A softener is not needed.

    Explore Whole-House + Softener Combo

Questions

Shelter Island Heights water FAQ

Free in-home test

See what’s really in your Shelter Island Heights water.

Published reports cover the public supply — a free in-home test measures your taps (and your well, if you have one), then we walk you through the results.